I used to tell my students that the best way to understand a country is to watch the people who tried to lead it. Not the marble statues — the human beings, making choices they couldn’t know the outcome of. I taught American history for thirty-one years in Chicago, and every September I’d start with the same question: “What do you think it feels like to be the person who has to decide?”
The answer is almost never what we expect. We imagine presidents who were born knowing what to do. Biographies tell a different story — men who were scared, who second-guessed themselves, who made catastrophic errors and somehow kept going. Leadership is usually just the accumulation of small, unglamorous decisions made when nobody was watching.
I didn’t start reading presidential biographies because I was interested in presidents. I started because I was interested in failure. I was twenty-six, in my fourth year of teaching, and I was bad at it. A veteran teacher handed me Caro’s The Years of Lyndon Johnson and said, “He was terrible at everything before he was good at anything.”
That book cracked something open. It showed me that the path from “bad at this” to “adequate” is not a straight line. It is a jagged, humiliating spiral that takes years. That was what I needed. Not a how-to guide. A confirmation that the struggle was normal.
Thirty-one years later, I’ve read somewhere north of two hundred presidential biographies. Some are doorstoppers you could use to prop open a fire door. Others are lean and sharp. The best ones, regardless of length, do the same thing: they make you feel like you’re in the room with someone who didn’t know how things would turn out.
Here’s what I’ve learned, and what I hope you’ll learn too: reading about presidents is not about memorizing dates or understanding policy. It is about watching human beings — flawed, ambitious, often deeply lonely human beings — try to do something hard. And if you watch long enough, you start to see patterns that apply to your own life.
Quick Pick: The Best Book for Learning About U.S. Presidents
If you only have time for one book, go with “Team of Rivals” by Doris Kearns Goodwin. It is the best single-volume entry point into presidential history because it does something no other book does: it shows you four presidents at once. Lincoln, Salmon Chase, William Seward, Edward Bates — all men who wanted the same thing, all thrown together in a cabinet, all forced to figure out how to work with people they didn’t trust. It is a masterclass in political genius, but more than that, it is a masterclass in how to collaborate with people you genuinely dislike. That is a skill that applies to every single human relationship.
The 10 BEST BOOKS FOR A BOOK ABOUT A U.S. PRESIDENT AND TRANSFORMING YOUR LIFE
1. TEAM OF RIVALS BY DORIS KEARNS GOODWIN
DORIS KEARNS GOODWIN | ⭐ 4.7/5
Who it’s for: Anyone who has ever had to work with someone they don’t like — which is to say, everyone.
“The best way to test a man’s character is to give him power.”
Lincoln’s answer to political enemies was not to destroy them but to bring them into his cabinet. He appointed Seward, Chase, and Bates — all rivals for the Republican nomination — to the highest positions. Goodwin’s genius is showing how he managed these relationships. He was politically ruthless when needed, but understood that the people who challenge you are often the ones who make you better.
My take: If you read one presidential biography in your life, make it this one. It will change how you think about disagreement.
2. JOHN ADAMS BY DAVID MCCULLOUGH
DAVID MCCULLOUGH | ⭐ 4.5/5
Who it’s for: Readers who feel like they’re the only one in the room who cares about doing things the right way.
“I must study politics and war that my sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy.”
John Adams is the most relatable president. This is not a widely held opinion, but I will die on this hill. Washington was too distant. Jefferson was too contradictory. But Adams — short, irritable, insecure, brilliant, convinced he was undervalued — is a person you recognize. He is the colleague who does the work and watches someone else get the credit. He is the friend who is right about everything and somehow still comes across as annoying.
McCullough’s biography captures this perfectly. He shows Adams as a man of enormous integrity and equally enormous ego, someone who could not stop himself from saying exactly what he thought, even when it cost him. His relationship with Abigail Adams is one of the great love stories in American history, and McCullough lets their letters speak for themselves. You watch two people build a country and a marriage at the same time, neither of which was easy.
I’ve given this book to at least a dozen former students who were struggling with feeling unheard. Adams’ story is a strange kind of comfort: it proves that you can be right and still be unpopular, and that sometimes the unpopular right person is exactly what history needs.
My take: Adams is the president for people who feel like they’re fighting alone. This book will remind you why the fight matters.
3. GRANT BY RON CHERNOW
RON CHERNOW | ⭐ 4.8/5
Who it’s for: Anyone who has ever failed at something and needed proof that failure is not the end of the story.
“I have never been an enthusiast in anything.”
Ulysses S. Grant is the great American redemption story. Before the Civil War, he was a failure at virtually everything — farming, business, the military. Then the war came, and he became the military genius who saved the Union. Then he was ruined by a swindler. Then he wrote the finest presidential memoirs in American history while dying of throat cancer.
Chernow does not soften Grant’s failures. He shows you the drinking, the bad business decisions, the naivete. And then he shows you how Grant kept getting up. Not gracefully, but with the grim determination of a man with no other option. His late-in-life pivot into writing his memoirs — at the urging of Mark Twain — is one of the great third acts in American history.
My take: Grant is proof that your early failures do not determine your final story. This is the biography for anyone who needs to be reminded of that.
4. THE RISE OF THEODORE ROOSEVELT BY EDMUND MORRIS
EDMUND MORRIS | ⭐ 4.6/5
Who it’s for: People who feel physically or emotionally limited and need to see what raw willpower can accomplish.
“I have always been fond of the West African proverb: ‘Speak softly and carry a big stick; you will go far.'”
Theodore Roosevelt was a sickly, asthmatic child who decided — consciously, deliberately — to remake his body. He took up boxing, weightlifting, and horseback riding. He turned himself into a physical force of nature through sheer stubbornness. What Morris captures so brilliantly is that this same force applied to everything Roosevelt did: politics, conservation, writing, exploration. He lived about three lives’ worth of experience in one.
Morris won the Pulitzer for this book, and you can feel why on every page. He has a novelist’s sense of pacing and a historian’s rigor. The set pieces — the Rough Riders charging up San Juan Hill, Roosevelt’s cattle ranching in the Badlands, his ascent to the presidency after McKinley’s assassination — are rendered with cinematic detail. But the quieter moments are what stay with me. Roosevelt reading a book a day. Roosevelt writing to his children from the White House. Roosevelt, alone at night, still that sickly boy who had decided he would not be defined by his limitations.
My take: Morris makes you believe that willpower can overcome almost anything. This is the book I recommend to anyone who says “I can’t.”
5. A PROMISED LAND BY BARACK OBAMA
BARACK OBAMA | ⭐ 4.9/5
Who it’s for: Anyone who has ever wondered what it actually feels like to be in the room where decisions are made.
“Democracy is not a gift from on high but something founded on empathy and common understanding and built together, day by day.”
Obama’s memoir is unusual in the presidential canon because it was written by the president himself while the events were still settling. Most presidential memoirs are either ghostwritten or guarded. This one is neither. Obama writes with a novelist’s attention to detail and a philosopher’s willingness to interrogate his own motives.
What surprised me most was how honest he is about the loneliness of the job. He describes walking the halls of the White House at night, wondering if he was making the right call on Afghanistan, on the stimulus, on health care. He admits when he wasn’t sure. He names his mistakes. He writes about the toll the presidency took on his marriage, his daughters, his sense of self. This kind of vulnerability is rare in any genre. In a presidential memoir, it is virtually unheard of.
I assigned excerpts to my seniors in the final years of my teaching career, and the conversation that followed was unlike any I’d had in thirty years. They didn’t want to talk about policy. They wanted to talk about what it means to carry responsibility for other people.
My take: This is the most honest first-hand account of the presidency ever written. Read it for the humanity, stay for the prose.
6. DESTINY OF THE REPUBLIC BY CANDICE MILLARD
CANDICE MILLARD | ⭐ 4.5/5
Who it’s for: Readers who love a gripping narrative and want to discover a president they know nothing about.
“He had been a president for only four months. He had not even had time to fail.”
James Garfield is the president Americans know least about, and his story is the most surprising. Born in abject poverty, he became a scholar, a Civil War hero, a congressman, and then president — all before being shot by a deranged office-seeker who believed God told him to do it. The shooting didn’t kill Garfield. The doctors did. Their primitive, unsterilized treatment of his wound led to an infection that killed him over the course of eleven agonizing weeks.
Millard tells this story with the pacing of a thriller — weaving together Garfield’s biography, the assassin’s delusions, and Alexander Graham Bell’s failed attempt to use his new invention to locate the bullet. The history of medicine is the real villain. Doctors refused to believe germs caused infection, and their arrogance cost a president his life.
My take: If you think presidential history is boring, start here. Millard writes like your favorite crime novelist.
7. WASHINGTON: A LIFE BY RON CHERNOW
RON CHERNOW | ⭐ 4.6/5
Who it’s for: Anyone who needs to see how a person can maintain their integrity in a position of enormous power.
“Few men have virtue to withstand the highest bidder.”
Washington spent his entire life constructing a public image of stoic invulnerability. Chernow gets past it, showing a man of fierce ambition, volcanic temper, and deep attachments — who taught himself to suppress all of it because the country needed a president who appeared above the fray.
The detail that stopped me cold: Washington owned more than 300 enslaved people. He opposed slavery in principle, freed his own slaves in his will, but never spoke out against it publicly. Chernow does not flinch. He presents Washington as a man who made a moral compromise for political stability and spent the rest of his life not quite at peace with it. That makes him more interesting, not less.
My take: Chernow gives us a Washington who is human-sized — which makes his accomplishments even more remarkable.
8. THE BULLY PULPIT BY DORIS KEARNS GOODWIN
DORIS KEARNS GOODWIN | ⭐ 4.6/5
Who it’s for: People interested in how friendship and rivalry can coexist, and how journalism shapes politics.
“The president is the steward of the people’s welfare.”
Goodwin’s second appearance on this list is justified because The Bully Pulpit is not really a repeat. It is a different kind of book. Where Team of Rivals is about collaboration among enemies, this one is about the slow, painful unraveling of a friendship. Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft were genuine friends before politics tore them apart. Goodwin tells both stories simultaneously — Roosevelt’s progressive fire, Taft’s more cautious conservatism — and shows how two good men who respected each other ended up destroying their relationship over principle.
The third thread in this book is the rise of investigative journalism, specifically the muckrakers at McClure’s Magazine. Ida Tarbell, Lincoln Steffens, Ray Stannard Baker — these journalists were as important to the Progressive Era as any politician. Goodwin weaves their stories in with Roosevelt and Taft’s, creating a portrait of an America that was arguing about exactly the same things we argue about now: inequality, corporate power, corruption, the role of the press.
I used the chapter on Tarbell’s investigation of Standard Oil when I taught journalism as a senior elective. It holds up.
My take: A masterclass in how to tell a complex story about complicated people. Goodwin’s best work after Team of Rivals.
9. LEADERSHIP IN TURBULENT TIMES BY DORIS KEARNS GOODWIN
DORIS KEARNS GOODWIN | ⭐ 4.5/5
Who it’s for: Anyone currently navigating a difficult period and looking for models of resilience.
“The best leaders are those who never stop learning.”
This is the book I hand to people who say “I don’t have time for a 700-page biography.” It distills Goodwin’s decades of presidential research into a single volume about how leaders are made — not born. She studies Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, FDR, and LBJ through the lens of adversity: what broke them, what didn’t, and how they emerged from crisis with new capabilities.
The structure is brilliant. Each section examines a different phase: the ambition that drove them into politics, the adversity that nearly ended them, and the crucible moments where they became the leaders history remembers. Lincoln’s depression. TR’s grief. FDR’s polio. LBJ’s humiliation in his first political campaign. Goodwin shows that none of these men were naturally suited for leadership. They became suited for it by surviving things.
I’ve been wrong about this before. I used to think leaders were born with something the rest of us lack. I’m less wrong now. Goodwin’s research confirms what I suspected at the end of my career: the people we call leaders are just people who kept showing up after everyone else stopped.
My take: This is the executive summary of a lifetime of scholarship. It belongs on every shelf.
10. HIS VERY BEST: JIMMY CARTER, A LIFE BY JONATHAN ALTER
JONATHAN ALTER | ⭐ 4.4/5
Who it’s for: Readers who want proof that a failed presidency can be followed by a triumphant life.
“I have one life and one chance to make it count for something.”
Jimmy Carter is perhaps the most misunderstood president in American history. Elected in the aftermath of Watergate, he was a Washington outsider who never learned to work the levers of power. His presidency was marked by economic turmoil, the Iran hostage crisis, and a general sense of drift. He lost reelection in a landslide. By any conventional measure, his presidency was a failure.
And then he lived another forty-three years.
Alter’s biography is the first to fully reckon with both halves of Carter’s life. The pre-presidential half — farm boy, naval officer, peanut farmer, governor — and the post-presidential half, which is arguably the most consequential in American history. Carter built houses for Habitat for Humanity. He eradicated diseases in Africa. He won the Nobel Peace Prize. He became, improbably, the most admired former president the country has ever had.
I read this book during my second year of retirement, when I was still trying to figure out what to do with myself. Carter’s example — that your most important work might come after your most visible failure — was exactly what I needed.
My take: Carter’s story is proof that a life is measured by more than a single chapter. Essential reading for anyone starting over.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
WHICH PRESIDENTIAL BIOGRAPHY SHOULD I READ FIRST?
If you have never read a presidential biography, start with either Team of Rivals or John Adams. Both are accessible, beautifully written, and give you the full arc of a life without requiring prior knowledge. Team of Rivals is better if you’re interested in leadership and collaboration. John Adams is better if you’re interested in character and integrity. You cannot go wrong with either. After that, read Grant for the redemption story, then Washington: A Life for the foundation.
AREN’T PRESIDENTIAL BIOGRAPHIES REALLY LONG AND BORING?
The length is real. Most are 700-900 pages. But the best biographers — McCullough, Chernow, Goodwin — are extraordinary storytellers who use letters, diaries, and personal papers to reveal their subjects as full human beings. I’ve had students tell me they couldn’t put Grant down. A 900-page book.
WHAT CAN I ACTUALLY LEARN FROM READING ABOUT PRESIDENTS?
How to handle criticism (Lincoln read his hate mail and responded with patience). How to bounce back from failure (Grant’s entire life is a case study). How to maintain relationships under strain (Adams’ letters to Abigail). How to find purpose after your main chapter ends (Carter’s post-presidency). The larger lesson is harder to name — something about watching people carry weight and not collapse under it.
HOW DO I CHOOSE WHICH PRESIDENT TO READ ABOUT?
Start with the president you know least about. The best reading experiences come from discovery. I knew almost nothing about James Garfield before Destiny of the Republic, and it was one of the most gripping reads of my life. If you have a personal connection — your hometown, a policy area you care about, a historical period that fascinates you — follow that thread. The books will take you where you need to go.
ARE THERE ANY PRESIDENTIAL BIOGRAPHIES I SHOULD SKIP?
Yes. There are biographies that are either hagiographies (uncritical praise) or hit jobs (relentless criticism). Neither is useful. The best presidential biographies are the ones that treat their subjects as complicated human beings. If a biography feels like it’s trying to sell you on someone’s greatness, put it down. If it feels like it’s trying to tear someone down, put it down faster. The truth is always in the middle.
WHAT IF I DON’T FINISH A 900-PAGE BIOGRAPHY?
Then you’re in good company. I have started at least fifteen biographies I never finished. Some of them I plan to go back to. Some of them I probably won’t. Reading a presidential biography is not a moral test. Read the chapters that interest you. Skip the sections on tariff policy if that’s not your thing. The goal is not to finish. The goal is to spend time with someone whose life can teach you something.
THE BOTTOM LINE
I taught American history for thirty-one years, and the question I heard most often was “Why does this matter?” Because the people who came before us were not smarter or braver than we are. They were people who chose to keep going. The presidents here — Lincoln, Adams, Grant, TR, Obama, Garfield, Washington, Carter — all had moments where they could have stopped. They didn’t. Not because they were extraordinary, but because they had decided the work was worth doing.
If I had to recommend three of these ten to start with, I’d say: Team of Rivals for the lesson in collaboration, Grant for the lesson in resilience, and Destiny of the Republic for the pure pleasure of a great story well told. The rest will find you when you need them.
Which book are you grabbing first?
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, ReadPlug may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend books we’ve personally found valuable.
